WoW Forever Gold Exploit: Blackmaw Hold Bans and Streamer Drama
The WoW Forever gold exploit surfaced over the weekend of November 14-15, when about 30 regular Blackmaw Devotees in Blackmaw Hold - due to a bug - dropped loot from elite mobs, earning farmers thousands of gold. On November 16, Blizzard patched the exploit with a hotfix and suspended trading on a couple hundred accounts, and on November 17, began taking the ill-gotten gains and issuing temporary bans. The 7-day suspension, as described by streamer Ziqo himself, did not quell the controversy, because the community saw him farming live and is demanding that the same measures be applied to him as to regular players.
How the Blackmaw Devotee Farm Worked
About 30 regular Blackmaw Devotees were standing in a group in Blackmaw Hold and dropping the full loot meant for elite mobs. This level 55-60 dungeon with seven bosses is hidden in the Blackmaw clan's furbolg tunnel in Azshara. Players stumbled upon this generous pack over the weekend of November 14-15.
In a blue post on November 17, Kaivax from Blizzard acknowledged that these mobs were "incorrectly dropping the full amount of dungeon loot that would be expected from an elite." The loot from a single Devotee consisted of coins, a Mote of Unstable Magic, and a Blackmaw Pouch:
| What dropped from a single Devotee | Price |
|---|---|
| Coins from the mob | 25-30 silver |
| Mote of Unstable Magic | around 13 silver on the auction house |
| Blackmaw Pouch | around 1g |
Devotees were melee mobs, so mages would herd them into a single group and incinerate them with area-of-effect spells. This tactic yielded 100-160 gold per hour, according to players' own estimates. For the sake of this income, most farmers in Blackmaw Hold chose to play a mage, though other classes were also present there. The fix came out as early as Monday because this kind of profit is enormous for a game that's been out for just 2 weeks.
Blizzard's Response: Hotfix, Economy Lock and Gold Removal
Kaivax summarized Blizzard's response in a blue post on November 17, although the first measures took effect as early as November 16. Early that morning, a hotfix came out, after which Blackmaw Devotee mobs stopped dropping elite loot. A couple hundred accounts worldwide were placed under an economy lock that same day to prevent gold from the Devotee from flooding the market until the investigation was complete. The consequences came on November 17, when Blizzard began deducting gold from players who had exploited the bug and issuing temporary bans to major offenders. Two weeks passed between the launch of World of Warcraft Forever and the dispute over the length of the penalties:
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| November 4 | Launch of World of Warcraft Forever |
| November 14-15 | Blackmaw Devotee bug over the weekend |
| November 16 | Hotfix and trading freeze |
| November 17 | Kaivax's post, first penalties |
| November 18 | Xaryu's video and debate over penalty durations |
Kaivax summed up the gold confiscation and bans in a single sentence: "Today, we are in the process of removing all such gold earned, as well as applying account suspensions to significant abusers." The same post explains why the company considers the search for profitable gold farming to be normal: players have been saving up for epic mounts this way since 2004. But if a single spot overshadows all other sources of gold in Forever, Blizzard levels the playing field. With the Blackmaw Devotee pack, it was no longer a matter of a profitable route but a bug, because the elite loot from regular mobs in Blackmaw Hold cannot be explained by luck.
What the Economy Lock Blocks
The economy lock cuts you off from mail, trading, and the auction house while Blizzard investigates your account's Devotee income. You won't be able to transfer gold to an alt or list a Mote of Unstable Magic for sale until the company reaches a decision. If you managed to sell the bugged items to a vendor, Blizzard will also take the proceeds, because it considers them to be income derived from the bug.
On November 17, Kaivax reassured those who were just running the dungeon: "Players who simply ran Blackmaw Hold a few times and benefited organically from the extra loot did nothing wrong." Your account is not at risk for just running Blackmaw Hold boss fights.
How Long Are the Exploit Bans
Bans last from 1 to 7 days, based on the emails received by those who were penalized. Blizzard does not publish an official scale and does not comment even on closed accounts, which individual players have reported. The range is evident in five known cases:
| Case | Penalty | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Reddit poster | 24 hours | over 6,000g from the bug |
| Guild, four accounts | 1 day for three, 3 days for one | emails naming the violation |
| Alt account that got items | auction house ban | no account suspension |
| Ziqo | 7 days | reported it himself |
| Individual accounts | account closure | no comment from the company |
On November 17, the author of a Reddit post revealed that he had farmed over 6,000 gold from the bug and got off with a 24-hour ban. In the same post, he admitted: "As fun as it was to farm over 6,000 gold, we all know it probably shouldn't have been there to begin with." After the ban, the character's bags contained just 98 gold, 37 silver, and 21 copper. He didn't have fast riding before either.
Four players from one guild received letters from Blizzard citing "Exploitation of game mechanics" and imposing bans ranging from 1 to 3 days. The company was more lenient with the alt account that received items from the farming account: Blizzard disabled just its auction house access. As a result, the ban meant less of a loss: the gold removal hit harder than a day without playing.
Ziqo, Sodapoppin and the Streamer Debate
On November 14, Ziqo - a mage streamer and AWC tournament commentator - farmed Blackmaw Devotees live on stream and promised to keep farming the pack until it was nerfed. He warned the chat in advance: "If I come back with 5,000 gold, don't ask any questions." As a result, viewers saw the mage had 4,322 gold. Ziqo himself wrapped up his Devotee session with the line, "My only regret, guys, is that I slept for four hours."
Even before the blue post, Ziqo had argued on X that Blackmaw Devotees and regular furbolgs in Winterspring shared the same loot table. Based on this, the mage boiled the entire debate over Blackmaw Hold down to the formula: "OP Farm yes, bugged/exploitative no." But on November 17, Ziqo himself reported that he had received a 7-day ban.
Ziqo didn't hide his teammates either. He claims that Sodapoppin turned off his own stream and was farming alongside him on a druid. The mage named another participant: the hunter Brucewayner. No comments from Sodapoppin or Brucewayner on this matter have surfaced yet.
Ziqo also had to explain a screenshot from his stream. It shows a highlighted auction lot of 238 Arcane Crystals for 1,854 gold. The mage insists that he didn't buy the crystals, but used his earnings to purchase just a mount and ten Arcanite Bars.
To the Forever community, this whole situation looks like a double standard: Blizzard bans regular accounts but says nothing about streamers. On Reddit, this criticism led to a "Ban Ziqo" thread, which garnered over 5,000 upvotes on r/classicwow. Even more commotion broke out under Kaivax's post in r/wowforever: about 7,600 upvotes and 1,900 comments. A separate petition calls for banning all Blackmaw Hold abusers. The official forum echoed this sentiment, where the top reply under the November 17 post read, "Perm ban them or it means nothing."
So far, the longest known temporary suspension is Ziqo's 7-day ban. But the debate continues, because Blizzard is still silent about separate accounts.
What Pikaboo, Xaryu and Other Streamers Think
In a video on November 17, Pikaboo called the removal of gold from the Blackmaw Devotee necessary and praised the developers' work. However, he rejects the idea of a permanent ban, since the Blackmaw Hold farmers didn't break anything in the game - they were just farming a generous pack. Among the streamers who supported the gold removal, Pikaboo took the softest stance: "So I'd say permanent ban is a little crazy."
On November 18, Xaryu released a video and suggested a stricter punishment: "I think the temp ban plus removing gold feels right." He considered just confiscating the gold from the Devotee insufficient, while a permanent ban was excessive. Xaryu calls the Blackmaw Hold incident a good precedent for every Forever player.
On X, Kungen - a well-known figure in the community - went even further. He demanded that all money from the bug be taken without delay and cited Guild Wars 2, where in 2017, violators received 3-day bans and lost their purchased items. But in Forever, Blizzard hasn't said whether the Skullflame Shield and other gold-purchased items from the Blackmaw Devotee will remain with their owners.
GuzuTV's video from November 17 takes the harshest stance of all. For GuzuTV, it's clear that the developers did not intend for players to farm the Devotee pack. He suggests that players who spent hours in Blackmaw Hold should forfeit more than their money: "It shouldn't just be the gold, it should also be all the items." GuzuTV makes no exceptions for streamers either.
In a blue post on November 17, Blizzard announced the very combination of confiscation and temporary account suspensions that Xaryu advocated for the following day. Major offenders were banned, rather than everyone who cleared Blackmaw Hold a couple of times.
Did the Exploit Ruin the Economy
As of November 18, the WoW Forever gold exploit hasn't crashed the game's economy, though traces of the bug are visible on the auction house and in character gear. There are four main indicators:
- Mote of Unstable Magic - after November 14, the number of lots on the auction house reached around 15,000 instead of 1,000, according to players' estimates. The price per item fell from 15 to 5 silver, since this Mote dropped from every Devotee.
- Expensive materials - many players complained that characters who had gotten rich from the bug were buying them up from the auction house.
- Skullflame Shield at level 55 - one player encountered a level 55 paladin with this shield, which (according to the paladin himself) was purchased with money from this bug.
- Purchased items - the Skullflame Shield and other purchases made with this money are still an open question, because Blizzard hasn't said a word about them.
The company explains the trade lock as a way to prevent this money from circulating in the economy while the investigation is ongoing. The combination of the trade lock and the confiscation has stopped the bulk of this type of income.
Gold That Stays in Your Bags
Gold from the bugged Blackmaw Hold farm doesn't stay in your bags: Blizzard takes it even after you sell items to a vendor, and the auction house has been closed for the alt character to whom the items were transferred. We advise you to stay away from such schemes, as Blizzard has added account suspensions of up to 7 days in addition to the gold confiscation. WoW Forever Gold allows you to buy gold with minimal risk and without exploits. Our boosters never use bug-based farming methods like the Blackmaw Devotee exploit because it's unsafe for both customers and the boosters themselves. ChaosBoost's three services are made for different scenarios in this situation:
- WoW Forever Gold gives you currency that's earned through standard methods without bugs for mounts, materials, or gear.
- WoW Forever US Gold and WoW Forever EU Gold replenish your character's wallet on servers in your region (US or EU), where players who've gotten rich through the exploit are buying up expensive resources at the auction house.
- WoW Forever Blackmaw Hold Boost offers an honest dungeon run with a group to obtain level 55-60 gear from seven bosses. This run doesn't involve hours of farming a single pack of Devotees, for which accounts were banned.
You can once again farm gear from Blackmaw Hold bosses without worrying about the Devotee issue, because the hotfix on November 16 restored Blackmaw Hold to its status as a regular dungeon.
Gold Exploit FAQ
Was the Blackmaw farm an exploit?
Blizzard classified the elite drop from regular Devotees as a bug, while standing near the same Devotee pack for hours on end was deemed an exploit. Of the four accounts from a single guild, three received a 1-day ban for this, and one received a 3-day ban.
Will normal dungeon runs get you banned?
On November 17, Kaivax exonerated everyone who entered Blackmaw Hold to fight bosses. Penalties went to those who stayed near the same Devotees for hours on end.
Does the gold farm still work?
No, after the hotfix on Monday, November 16, Blackmaw Devotees drop regular non-elite loot. The gold-farming window lasted just one weekend, November 14-15.
How long is the ban for the gold exploit?
Those penalized lost access to the game for periods ranging from 1 day to 1 week, though a few players report account closures that the company hasn't confirmed. Blizzard keeps its penalty scale confidential, so all figures are taken from players' own reports since November 17.
Did Ziqo get banned?
The mage himself announced the 7-day ban on November 17. Blizzard has not confirmed this duration, as the company does not disclose information about individual penalties in Forever.















