All the Tall Tales are now in my completed list. They guided me through every story mission, so I earned those exclusive rewards without getting stuck once.
Rewards
These big Sea of Thieves quests come with treasure troves of rewards. Completing these elaborate quests gives you a mix of gold, glory and unique loot. Here’s what’s in the chest for pirates who finish these quests:
- Heaps of Gold: Every completed Sea of Thieves tale drops 8,000 gold into your account. That’s a nice chunk of change to spend at the Outpost on new sails, cosmetic upgrades or just a night of celebratory grog.
- Unique Cosmetics: Each one unlocks exclusive Sea of Thieves cosmetic items for your pirate or ship. We’re talking legendary outfits, weapons, ship parts and even curses you can’t get anywhere else. (Yes, you can literally turn your pirate into a gold-statue-looking legend with the right quest reward!)
- Renown & Titles: They grant special titles and commendations. Show off labels like “Sailor of Stories” or “Seeker of Grand Adventure” in your pirate profile. These bragging rights let everyone know you’ve completed the hardest content Sea of Thieves has to offer.
- Commendations for Completionists: For the Sea of Thieves pirates who do everything the hard way, they have commendations that often require multiple playthroughs and finding hidden journals. Complete them all and you’ll unlock some of the rarest loot in the game (and a sense of pride only a true pirate legend knows).
Whether hunting for Sea of Thieves cosmetic curses or stacking commendations like doubloons, the rewards from Tall Tales offer a real sense of pirate prestige. No basic voyage grind matches the feeling of rocking into the tavern glowing with a Gold Hoarder or wielding Briggsy’s blade — that’s what separates deckhands from legends.




